ADT vs Protection 1 vs SimpliSafe: Home Security and Medical Alert Companies Compared
Airfare Daily Deals eCigarettes Eyeglasses Hotels Jewelry Online Backup Online Dating Online Printing Online Tickets Skin Care Textbook Rentals Vitamins Web Hosting Weddings
Find thousands of shopping-related forums
SEARCH
Home Security Systems Rankings Q&A Coupons Reviews Comparison Grid Directory Articles
Ask a Question about Home Security Systems

ADT vs Protection 1 vs SimpliSafe: Home Security and Medical Alert Companies Compared

ADT has the most features with each of their home security plans, plus they have several medical alert plans to choose from. ADT offers a 6-month money back guarantee. Protection 1 has several plans to choose from including a simple to use medical alert device. Protection 1 offers a guarantee that states they will pay $1,000 of your insurance deductible if you are burglarized. SimpliSafe sells home security systems that you install. After the costs for the equipment, which is yours to keep, the only cost is the monthly monitoring costs. There is no contract to sign and they offer a 60-day full money back guarantee and the equipment has a 3-year warranty.
Covered in this report
ADT — Best Features
They have the most plans to choose from for home security and medical alert monitoring.
They have a 6-month money back guarantee.
Best for: Those that need a comprehensive security system with the most features listed in each plan.
Protection 1 — Best Features
Protection 1 offers discounted prices at times.
They have a Safety Net Guarantee that states they will pay $1,000 of your insurance deductible if you are burglarized and their system was activated and functioning.
Best for: Customers that need a wireless home security system with a good selection of security cameras.
SimpliSafe — Best Features
There is no contract to sign.
They offer a 60-day money back guarantee for a full refund plus a 3-year full product warranty.
Best for: Those that need a security system for a small house, rental house, condo or apartment.
Review

ADT

ADT is probably the best known name in home security products. ADT began in 1874 as a telegraph company. As the telephone came to be more popular, they expanded their business. As early as 1940, they were in the business of fire detection and ultrasonic burglar alarms. Today, ADT has over 8 million customers in the United States and Canada.

ADT Home Security Features

ADT does much more than just keep your home and business safe from burglars. They have monitors for every situation that all homeowners can view and control from their home or smartphone. Their home protection products and features include:

  • Video Surveillance: With a choice of video cameras, you will always be alerted when something is not right at your home. You can view live video from your smartphone, sync the cameras to motion detectors and receive and record triggered events.
  • Remote Arm and Disarm: You can arm and disarm your ADT home security system from anywhere using a smartphone, tablet, or desktop computer. You can check the status of your security system as easy as checking emails.
  • Burglary Monitoring: Sensors are installed on the windows and doors which connect to your alarm system and to ADT’s professionals.
  • Heat and Smoke Monitoring: Their heat and smoke sensors will sound an alarm at the very first sign of smoke or the heat from fire. Even if the power has gone out, their fire and smoke alarms will work. These alarms can also contact the fire department.
  • Carbon Monoxide Monitors: Carbon monoxide is especially dangerous since it cannot be smelled or seen and is deadly. When carbon monoxide is detected, these alarms will alert you and if the carbon monoxide is at hazardous levels, the fire department will be alerted.
  • Locks: You can automatically control the locks when you are not at home. This allows you to let certain people in and then lock the doors again when they leave our home or office.
  • Video Doorbell: This feature makes anyone think that you are at home when you are not home. No matter where you are, if someone is on your property and rings the doorbell, you can talk to them from anywhere as if you were home. The video doorbell works with ADT Pulse.
  • Flood Monitoring: The sensors will alert you immediately whenever rising water is detected by one of the flood sensors in your home. You can also purchase a battery backup power supply in case the power goes out during flooding.
  • Light Control: Maybe you are on vacation or working all night, you can control the lights in your home remotely. Turn on and off certain lights at certain times making it look like someone is home. You can set the lights to come on when trespassers are detected.
  • Garage Door Control: Have you had those days at work, you start to wonder if you closed the garage door. You can control your garage door remotely from the app. You can also get alerts sent to you if the garage door has been open too long.

ADT Home Security Prices

You can call ADT or fill out a quick form on their website to get current prices for their home security products and new products, plus they often have specials listed. Each of their plans has the following features:

  • 24-hour alarm monitoring
  • Digital keypad
  • 3 door/window sensors
  • Infrared motion detector
  • High-decibel alarm siren
  • Backup battery
  • Wireless keychain remote
  • Yard sign and window decals

ADT offers five plans with the following monthly costs:

  • Essentials - $36.99
  • Essentials Plus - $42.99
  • Total Protection - $44.99
  • Total Protection Plus - $47.99
  • Premium Protection with ADT Pulse - $52.99

They have a $99 installation, installment, and equipment fee. The contract length is for 36 months.

ADT Medical Alert

In addition to home security, ADT also carries medical alert systems with the following features:

Features

Medical Alert Basic

In Home

Medical Alert Plus

In Home

On-The-Go

Mobile

Cost

$27.99 per month

$33.99 per month

$37.99 per month

Waterproof neck pendant or wristband

Yes

Yes

Yes

Fall detection pendant

No

Yes

Yes

Wireless connection

No

Yes

Yes

GPS locating capabilities

No

No

Yes

Mobile

No

No

Yes

High / low home temperature alert

Yes

Yes

No

All medical alert devices come with their senior-sensitive trained ADT Medical Alert Specialists to monitor alerts. Wireless connection means that a phone line is not needed; otherwise there must be a phone line.

Protection 1

Protection 1 was founded in 1988 and is the country’s largest full service security company. They are rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and have a 95% customer satisfaction rating. Their live monitoring and customer service is based in the United States.

Protection 1 Home Security Features

Protection 1 offers all the features that you would expect in a home security system. They offer home security and surveillance, remote security, wireless security and health monitoring.

With their video surveillance system, you can keep on eye on your home while on vacation, watch the kids, see who is at your front door before you open it, monitor the swimming pool, and remotely watch your home while away at work.

Protection 1 Video Surveillance Features

  • An easy to use interface
  • A web based video surveillance complete with full mobile access and control
  • Secure viewing and firewall friendly video streaming with wireless encryption
  • You will receive text and email alerts at the first sign of trouble
  • Event-driven video notification with adjustable video motion detection
  • You will have up to 100mb of video clip storage
  • Up to 6 cameras protecting your home

Wireless Video Surveillance with Cloud Storage

Protection 1 offers a good selection of high resolution home security cameras. With their wireless security system, you do not have to have a phone line in order to secure your home. Your home will be secured through a cellular connection or on the web.

  • Indoor wireless security cameras feature adjustable motion detection.
  • Outdoor wireless security cameras are rugged to withstand the elements. They feature adjustable motion detection triggers, and they give you high resolution day or night.
  • Pan and tilt wireless cameras have the ability to pan in and out. Images are saved digitally for viewing at a later time.
  • Protection 1 offers video storage services on their secure server.

Remote Security

Other home security features from Protection 1 include remote access. With remote access, you will be able to check on your home and what is going on at home while away. You are able to arm and disarm the security system remotely, unlock and lock doors, manage the lights and check the status of the thermostat.

With remote security access, you will be alerted to any significant event even if the alarm system has been disarmed.

Medical Alert Systems

Protection 1 also has a medical alert system that can give everyone a secure feeling. Being a senior citizen or someone that could need medical attention, it can be worrisome to be home alone or living alone. The medical alert system will make you feel safe and secure at home or away from your home.

The Protection 1 medical alert system works whether or not the home security system is on or off. Their medical alert system is easy to use by just pressing a button if needed. Pressing the button immediately alerts the Protection 1 monitoring center of a burglary or a medical emergency. The button has a 5-second lockout to protect against false alarms.

The Protection 1 medical alert system is small and can be worn on a wristband, clipped to clothing, belt clip or around the neck. When out of the house, it can easily be clipped to a car visor. Their medical alert system is monitored 24/7 and includes 2-way voice.

More Protection Services

In addition to the above home security and health monitoring services, Protection 1 also sells the following:

  • Heat Detection: This service monitors your home for extreme temperature, hot or cold. Heat can of course mean fire or some other sort of problem and extreme cold can break water pipes. Their heat monitor is inside the smoke detector and works in tandem with your wireless thermostat.
  • Smoke Detector: When smoke is detected, it will sound a loud alarm in the home and also send a signal to the Protection 1 monitoring service. The signal repeats every 20 seconds until the smoke is gone. During regular usage, the smoke detector sends an hourly status report to their monitoring service that informs them the alarm is working properly.
  • Carbon Monoxide Monitoring: Carbon monoxide is a poisonous gas that can occur from any gas appliance, like a gas stove, gas fireplace, gas furnace, hot water tanks, etc. Most people that are injured or die from carbon monoxide poisoning are sleeping and never know there is a leak. The Protection 1 carbon monoxide alarm will alert you when carbon monoxide levels are rising.
  • Flood Monitoring: The Protection 1 water and flood monitor will alert you to any type of flooding from a non-flammable conductive liquid. Water and flooding cannot only cause damage, it can be deadly if there is electricity involved and cause electrocution.

Protection 1 Plans and Prices

Protection 1 offers several plans to choose from. All plans include:

  • Fire, Carbon Monoxide and Water Protection
  • Intrusion Protection
  • 24/7 alarm monitoring

They have the following plans and prices:

Features

Secure

Secure +

Smart Control

Video

 

$34.99

$44.99

$49.99

$54.99

Video surveillance

     

Yes

Energy / home automation

   

Yes

Yes

Interactive control

   

Yes

Yes

Image motion sensor

   

Yes

Yes

2 – way voice

 

Yes

Yes

Yes

SimpliSafe

SimpliSafe was designed and founded by Chad Laurans in 2006 with the idea that being safe should be simple. The home security system he designed is easy to be self-installed that doesn’t require a phone line or a contract. Their home security system is wireless, cellular and customizable and perfect for a home, business, or apartment.

SimpliSafe Home Security Features

SimpliSafe is a home security system that monitors for burglars, smoke detection, carbon monoxide, indoor temperature, and water and flooding. SimpliSafe is easy to put together and configure, yet has as many great features as the other home security systems, features that include:

  • Fast Cellular Connection: With SimpliSafe, you do not have to have a phone line. They have partnered with Verizon and T-Mobile for reliable cellular connections.
  • 24/7 Monitoring and Dispatch: They will dispatch police for burglar alarms, and the fire department for smoke and carbon monoxide alarms. They will also make a courtesy call for water sensor alarms and freezing temperature alarms.
  • Remote Control: You are able to arm and disarm the alarm from anywhere you are at. You can monitor events at your home, monitor the indoor temperature to prevent freezing pipes and check the status of all alarms.
  • Secret Alerts: Secretly monitor important areas of your home like liquor cabinets, medicine cabinets, gun storage cabinets, and file cabinets.
  • Text and Email Alerts: You will be notified right away by text or email with any alarm alerts and activity alerts.
  • Smash Proof: SimpliSafe will notify the police in the event that someone smashed the keypad.
  • Power Outage Protection: SimpliSafe is powered by lithium batteries that last 5 years so you will be safe even if the power goes out.
  • Wireless Sensors: Their sensors have a 400’ range and the system is customizable to fit your needs.
  • Pet Safe: SimpliSafe uses precise motion sensors to ensure your pets will not trigger the alarms. Place your sensors in places where your pets cannot change them.

SimpliSafe Installation

SimpliSafe installs in under an hour and the security system arrives pre-programmed to work instantly.

SimpliSafe Guarantee and Warranty

If you are not happy with your SimpliSafe security system, you can return it within 60 days for a full refund and they will pay return shipping. They have a 3-year full product warranty.

SimpliSafe Prices

SimpliSafe offers several packages to choose from. All packages contain 1 base station, 1 wireless keypad and a keychain remote.

Ultimate

Master

Classic

Economy

Starter

$539.85

$449.87

$349.92

$259.95

$226.96

2 motion sensors

2 motion sensors

1 motion sensor

1 motion sensor

1 motion sensor

4 entry sensors

6 entry sensors

3 entry sensors

3 entry sensors

1 entry sensor

1 panic button

       

1 extra 105db siren

1 extra 105db siren

1 extra 105db siren

   

1 smoke detector

1 smoke detector

1 smoke detector

   

1 water detector

       

1 CO detector

       

1 freeze sensor

       

They also have a build your own customize package and you can buy refurbished security systems for a discount of up to 30%.

SimpliSafe monitoring costs are:

  • Standard:  Their monitors guard your home 24/7 and will send the police in an emergency for $14.99 per month.
  • Interactive: The mobile app allows you to control your system from anywhere. You will also get text and email alerts, and their secret alerts for $24.99 per month.

Pros and Cons

ADT

  • Pros: ADT offers numerous plans to choose from for home and business security. You can get a NEST learning thermostat installed at no cost with ADT Pulse. They have a 6-month money back guarantee.
  • Cons: the length of the contract is 36 months, which means if you don’t like the service and cancel outside of the 6 months, you will have to pay the remainder of the contract.

Protection 1

  • Pros: Protection 1 offers free equipment included and no money down. They also have a Safety Net Guarantee that states they will pay $1,000 of your insurance deductible if you are burglarized and their system was activated and functioning.
  • Cons: Their contract length is 36 months, which means that if you cancel, you will have to pay the remainder of the contract. Their base protection plan requires a phone line.

SimpliSafe

  • Pros: SimpliSafe not require a contract and you do not need to have a phone line. SimpliSafe has a 60- day money back guarantee and a 3-year warranty on the equipment.
  • Cons: You have to install the system yourself.
Additional Information
ADT
Need an answer?
Get insightful answers from community-recommended
experts
in Home Security Systems on Knoji.
Would you recommend this author as an expert in ?
You have 0 recommendations remaining to grant today.
Comments (0)
ABOUT THIS CONSUMER REPORT
RELATED OFFERS & COUPONS
ADT Coupons
Protection 1 Coupons
SimpliSafe Coupons
Top Related Deals
Extra $10 Off $70 or $20 Off $100 + Free Shipping @ PetSmart
Activate Coupon
46% Off + Free Shipping - Compact Juice Extractor @ Cooking.com
Activate Coupon
40% off Your Online Membership @ Angie's List
Activate Coupon
30% Off Sitewide @ Botanic Choice
Activate Coupon
17% Off Premium Brand Coffees @ Coffee Wholesale USA
Activate Coupon
RELATED ARTICLES